Redesigning Your Own Site

by Lea Alcantara

35 Reader Comments

Back to the Article
  1. In my eyes this article points out very well the most important aspect of redesigning: maintaining some characteristics of the old website that identify the brand. You cannot simply restart from the beginning, but you have to make the redesign the obvious continuation of what existed before. I think this is an issue that many designers ignore. For instance, the SourceForge.net site undergoes many complete redesigns and every time it causes me to feel uncomfortable for a while.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  2. This is how redesign addiction begins. 

    I find it hard to be able to stick with any particular design on one of my own sites for the same reasons as above.  You become your own worst critic and every time you perfect a new technique on a client’s web site you start to wonder if you should incorporate it into your own.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  3. I’m surprised nobody comments about strategy/concept/guidelines/testing.
    I feel the main issue on redesigning your own web site as a designer (as I am) is to focus which informations are important/strategic for THE CLIENT and not for yourself. As you know your own business very well, you’re not objective about it, so you should have a panel of testers.
    I am currently redesigning my own site and I’m following an approach I feel being very effective.

    1. First of all I’ve set up my communication goals (they’ve changed since my actual site design).

    2. I’ve challenged them with some people that work in close-to-design-fields.

    3. I’ve decided (but not designed) the overall look&feel;/concept of the new graphic design.

    4. Than I roughly sketched the main pages prototypes on paper to define the elements density and the main grid.

    5. I’ve asked for a feedback to people on stage 2.

    6. I’ve designed in Photoshop all the website pages as high-definition wireframes including real labels, texts, and icons.

    7. I’ve put online a quick&dirty; html prototype of the wireframed site and tested it with a panel of about 20 persons of different ages and profiles. I’ve received many feedbacks about labelling, message clarity etc. I’ve made modifications and resent for new feedbaks 1/2 more times.  It was great and surprising! At this step your communication quality raises up dramatically.

    8. Finally I’ve started graphic design. Following the main idea I’ve decided at the beginning, I’ve tested different design versions, always testing them on several people, decreasing in number .
    That means I’ve answered to people having some negative feedbacks and proposing them new solutions (1 issue for 1 tester) but integrating all the feedbacks at the same time.

    ‘Layout Changes each Tester sees’ = N*(issue*Tester)

    Surprisingly, once an issue is fixed with one Tester, it is (almost always) OK for all the others.

    By the way during the graphic design phase I’ve reduced the columns from 9 (in the wireframe) to 8 and changed the Navigation Menu position, but it annoyed nobody as the concept and structure were coherent.

    9. now I’m designing in Photoshop all the pages to create then pixel perfect html+Jquery templates to be transformed in php (not by me).

    AND SO WHAT?  aka THE SUMMARY
    1. A designer can’t be objective about her/himself and her/his work.
    2. She/he needs a panel of testers (they can be friends, friend’s parents, colleagues etc.). The statistical error decreases quickly with number (N) of testers. 6 is an acceptable number; 9 is a good number; 20 is an excellent number!
    3. As a Freelance portfolio is a commercial/marketing tool, the contents must be defined and tested Before the graphic design.
    4.Of course the risk is to follow into a conforming consensus.
    5.Beware of feedback afterwords (“People on twitter say they like my new website”). People avoid negative comments if they feel isn’t useful. And on an already finished site is USELESS.
    The inquiries can grow because we have a simple “activation effect” caused by the change itself. Human neuronal system activates on state-change detection. The famous “Buzz effect” activates the neuronal system too. Both combined can drive to curiosity (approaching) or repulsion (escaping). It is the base of advertising.

    I do not judge Lea’s graphic design. I do not really mind about that.
    Only one remark : she says “the old design looked too much like a stereotypical Web 2.0 site.”; I feel her new web site to be better than the older one, but stereotypical as well ( I should say Worpress!)

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  4. I love #13’s point about redesign addiction. It is a serious problem for designers. As new uses of CSS and JQuery are showing up all over the place, it is tempting to implement them as soon as you can.

    How do you know that you REALLY need to redesign your site? Who knows! I think one of the most important steps is to not be stubborn. If you have put a ton of work into a design and it isn’t working, you need to be honest with yourself and decide when you start over.

    I wrote an “article”:http://christophermeeks.com/archives/391 about how to decide when to switch things up, it has gotten some pretty positive feedback as well.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  5. This is like a déja-vu, i’m planning this myself for a few months and have drawn sketches but i have a really difficult client, me! I guess this situation will be familiar to every designer who redesigns his or her own site, pure horror sometimes.

    Like your new design and thanks for the article, this is a great support !

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  6. Sometimes I feel like ALA practically reads my mind at times.  After seeing this article pop up in my RSS feed, I am more than convinced.

    After the small design firm I worked for closed in April due to the owner’s illness, I found myself looking for work again, yet making sure I keep my design skills sharp.  I started taking on more freelance work, when one of my friends asked me why I hadn’t considered working towards getting my own site back up and running again. 

    After half a notebook worth of notes and many cups of coffee later, I too realized that I am my worst client.  After reading this article, I actually think I can now get a better handle of getting the proverbial ball rolling.  I should have thought about going to some of my peers before now, but I just sent out a few feelers to see if I can get some insight from those who know me best.

    Great job on reading my mind.  And your redesign is outstanding!

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  7. Thanks for a great article. It’s funny how common it is that freelancers and even agencies neglect their own site. It’s easy to do since that particular client, yourself, doesn’t pay or the work. It’s a long term investment.

    BTW: I love the artwork at the top of the article. Kudos to the illustrator!

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  8. Thanks for this article, very enjoyable, and an awful lot of it rang true.
    It’s very tempting as a website builder to keep fiddling with your own personal site, but to some extent you must trust yourself to leave alone for a while and let it bed down properly.
    Also, before a redesign, have a look at your analytics data over a period of time to see which pages are working and which are not.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  9. I agree wholeheartedly with your article, so true.  I will say that I’ve never been happy with any design I made for my own sites, it just never seems to be enough – even if I get a bunch of compliments on it.  Anyway, thanks for sharing that sentiment – I’m glad I’m not alone :)

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  10. I’ve been agonizing over my own re-design for three months. I have a killer design but I get so sick of looking at it and now I want something different – before I’ve even launched it! – Tim Piele

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  11. Just joined ALA and browsing through Articles.  It caught my attention which means its time for me to go back and re-visualize what I really wanted to show.  Having a template based portfolio is not that bad when you are starting out.  But when you start growing – you’re right!, it is better to showcase what you have learned and show that you are on top of things.  Great Post and glad to be here.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  12. I too found this timely (even though I just got around to reading it!) I have been struggling with a redesign of my own website for a couple of months. The article made me wonder why I do not follow the process that I give to my clients when undertaking a redesign project. Thanks for the eye-opener.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  13. I am currently trying to redesign my own site and this article has really given me perspective on the idea of making a more user friendly site.
    Thanks the inspiration.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  14. I recently re-designed my portfolio website, and I must say I carried out of the project with the intention of keeping it simple with a white background etc. As I developed the site I found it easier to implement new design ideas into the layouts without getting too hung up on the overall look and feel of the site. Sometimes I think you can try too hard! Keep it simple!

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  15. I was giggling all the time reading through your article, to my mind it’s written rather good…and funny-))
    I’d like to say that we (designers) should always live in “NOW” which means we should provide to our clients up-to-date techniques/design and…DO NOT FORGET ABOUT OURSELVES! For ex. – do little changes every month. Edit your logo – make it animated or smting like that-)

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  16. I’m also a freelance web designer up in New York and I agree that redesigning a website for yourself can be the most challenging thing you can ever do.Many times we take tons of time learning what our customers businesses are about and what their target market is. They tell us what type of design they prefer and how much time and money they want to spend. Ourselves on the other hand; we are many times perfectionist who won’t launch until we have a perfect design and marketing strategy. And seeing that we’re doing the work ourselves we don’t need to worry about budget. We can take as long as we want and build our site as fancy as we want.

    But like mentioned. Our site might be stellar and impressive but if our target audience doesn’t think so or plain hates it, the site is a failure. My site is outdated also and lately I’ve been too much of a perfectionist. I guess it’s time to just redesign and take it from there.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  17. Designing your own site with the user in mind has always worked for me.  We designed our page thinking about the user experience… now it’s not perfect by any means but we’ve kept it simple and clean… we have some content issues at the moment but are working through this.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  18. Well, I can say is that your article is very good and reminds a lot about me and how I feel sometimes when I need to redesign my website…
    It was fun reading it :)

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  19. Amazing article ! It gives a lot of ideas about how can change your website layout in a simple and intelligible way. Normally I’ve use themes created by other designers but I think I must change this type of vision.

    I will try to make my own website look with this inspirational article in mind.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  20. Really good article and couldn’t agree more!
    So hard to stick to a design when every few days you come across an incredible new site that just does things a little differently

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  21. For me, redesigning a website is all about planning.  I need to lay everything out, put it all in steps and then execute.  If there’s something that doesn’t fit, back to the drawing board.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  22. redesigning you website is sometimes needed, but don’t forget to catch the old web url’s with a 301 redirect! And get a custom 404 error page with webanalytics installed on it… you’ll learn alot when checking your webstatistics of that errorpage …

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  23. Very interesting and helpful article on the process of redesigning. We find it the hardest thing to redesign our own website. The design is never good enough and we have the highest expectations from ourselves. We did around four-five designs in order to decide on the best take.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  24. Loved this article, and you have some great suggestions that I will be following. I am just about to start our sites re-design so yeah, thanks! very useful article.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.