Comments on The Rules of Digital Engagement

21 Reader Comments

Back to the Article
  1. Interesting article.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  2. Where I work we communicate almost exclusively via chat, even though we have a shared workspace (it’s so we don’t have to take our headphones off), while with my own usually non-technical freelance clients I find that many of them end up breathing a sigh of relief when I finally get around to picking up the phone and calling them.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  3. I work daily with designers and developers across the US, and truth be told, I have a much easier time working on challenging projects when there *is* a geographic split.

    I’ve noticed a tendency of people to over-communicate (in a good way) through very concise bursts of information when there are a few states/timezones splitting up the team. When the entire group is under one roof there is a tendency to schedule excess status meetings, or make possibly false assumptions regarding who is working on which parts of a given task - e.g. _I saw the presentation deck up on Kevin’s screen, so he must be working on it._

    Since line of sight can’t be established, folks tend to send out more informal, more helpful status updates. It seems like the quantity of <3 minute iChat video conferences and the quality of SVN comments on file commits skyrocket when I am not sitting within earshot of the person I am working with. There is still certainly a time and a place for groups to huddle together in a room and slug through big projects, but through the glories of telepresence I don’t think it is required quite as often as it once was. I think the requirement for a successful project is clear and open communication, not physical face-time.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  4. Maintaining contact between all team members is so important. In past projects I’ve seen team members go dark for days only to come out of their cave with either not much done or they took something in the wrong direction.

    Leverage the tools that are out there => “Campfire”: , IRC, IM, or whatever.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  5. Where I work we have a combination of communication. Ichat, email, face to face, phone. It seems to me like the best is always face to face to get a point across, although raw information always works better in a text format for me. Probably because I can save it and come back to it later if needed.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  6. I don’t think that relationships in virtual team needs to be that tight (e-mails every day, VOIP all day). That sounds absolutely wrong. I work on client’s accounts every day communicating over Basecamp or Campfire approx. once a week. You don’t need to communicate that often when you keep it all logged. And as far as deliverables are met, it is OK to keep in touch once a week. It is very important to setup clear performance targets and stick to the deadlines.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  7. In fact I do SEO and off-site marketing. I’d imagine that “campfire once a week” + “monthly reports” wouldn’t work for graphic design.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  8. Depends on the project, but I don´t think that it is necessary to have contact every day. It is important to spend more time to unexperienced team members or with lower skills to meet the goal of the project.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  9. Hi All,
    Thanks for the comments so far. I find extremely interesting the varying opinions regarding staying in touch on virtual teams. While Matt talks about the possible pitfalls of team members “going dark” for a few days, Frantisek describes a situation where checking in once a week is acceptable. I think these variations are a perfect example of some of the issues I covered under the article section “Respecting Others’ Communication Styles”. And Frantisek also points out that different jobs and roles may require different levels of communication.

    I personally have had more experiences similar to Matt’s, and I tend to like to talk to team members pretty often. So, as project manager on a Web dev job, I’m likely to want to hear from people at least once a day, whether it’s via IM, e-mail, VOIP, conference call or whatever. Sometimes I multitask, holding an IM conversation while writing an e-mail or talking on Skype.

    At any rate, the whole virtual team method of working is still in its infancy, and it will be a long while before we’re able to figure out its best practices. But, it won’t be a dull ride.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  10. It is important that teams distributed along the long corridor are not virtual but real. Real people, real roles.
    I always find it good to have one or more audioconferences to establish the reality of other team members.
    Communications are then dictated by the roles. Leaders may need to contact some individual members regularly, collaborative authors may collaborate on a wiki with regular but asynchronous communication, others may prefer to work in isolation but regularly update the team leader.
    Nice article it highlights a problem we are all just feeling our way through.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  11. I find that the appropriate frequency of contact has a few variables.  The first is the time line and phase of the project.  Projects with a longer time line tend to need less contact, especially in the middle stages, after the initial flurry of organizing the project has died down.  The contact frequency usually increases towards the end.  Increased contact is often needed around project milestones, or phases that involve a lot of integration.

    The second variable is the nature of the work of the team members.  This is often difficult to manage as team members who tend to need more contact such as graphic designers, sometimes have trouble relating to those writing long-form content, who seem to need much less.  There is a real art to structuring communication channels so they provide useful feedback for those that need it, and space for those that don’t.

    Finally there is the communication style of the individual worker, and finding a balance between their personal comfort and that of their team members.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  12. I live and work in europe. I have spent many years working with people in the US, far-east and other parts of the world. One thing that has not been mentioned, but is critical to a team’s understanding is that people are NOT instantly available. If you’re in LA, but the time you start work on friday I have already “gone home” (metaphorically - i.e. I won’t communicate with you) for the weekend. On my monday morning I’ll pick up your “this is an emergency: I’ve got to have your input within the next hour” email or voicecomm. Similarly, if your colleague in Tel-Aviv needs to get in touch, well tough - you don’t share any common “office hours” so every communication will take a day to turn around.

    Having said that, the time differential can be leveraged. If I am working on a problem during the day, I can pass it on to someone in Calif. when I knock off. Likewise they can pass it on to someone in Islamabad after their 8 hours and I’ll get it back from pakistan when I come in. That’s 3 shifts, all following the sun.

    It takes a lot of flexibility and planning. You also have to take into account national holidays (I work on July 4 and thanksgiving, but don’t expect to hear for me on 8 other days - up to 16 if I was spanish)
    And don’t even get me started on cultural differences: siesta? Grrrrr.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  13. I agree that communication is key in any facet of life, work, home, where ever. The majority of the conflict I’ve seen has been due to a simple mis-communication. When you don’t have conversations you can disconnect from the individual and are less likely to be receptive to an idea (in my opinion).

    “Simply saying “I hear you”? or “I understand”? can work wonders, even if that’s all you offer, in the end, to solve the problem.”

    I wholeheartedly disagree with this statement, when I’m working with a project manager and have a problem I don’t want to hear “I understand” or “I hear you”. I’d like to hear “What can we do about this?”.

    While venting can do a world of good, from what I’ve found, it only puts off the conflict for a little longer as it builds; which may be fine on a short project. I would especially have a problem if the project manager was placating the whole team with things like “I hear you”, really never taking a stand for anything. Maybe because I picture it being said in the midst of work with a head down, not really paying attention… that’s probably why.

    Good article though, I like the idea of having a meeting in the middle of a long project just to see how things are going and the postmortem one afterwards

    my2cents..well, maybe 3

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  14. Thanks for the comments, Pete and Tim.

    Great point, Pete, about timezones and the benefits and difficulties of working on different continents. I think that, as virtual teams become more accepted as a way to do business, we’ll be seeing lots of people working this way. I imagine that the ins and outs of running a global virtual team could provide fodder for a complete article in itself. Thanks for your insights.

    Tim, when I was writing that recommendation about “simply saying ‘I hear you’ or ‘I understand’”, I was remembering a situation I encountered on a project where, as project manager, there was nothing I could do to fix it. Being a sympathetic ear to a team member who wanted to vent was really all I could offer. I wanted to show respect for the person, and let them know I would stand by them during a tense, and difficult situation with the client. So, I found myself saying those phrases quite a bit. Probably not the most elegant way to handle the problem, but it worked and we delivered the product. Sometimes there’s merit in just making it all the way through a project, especially with virtual teams.




    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  15. @Jonathan

    bq. Sometimes I multitask, holding an IM conversation while writing an e-mail or talking on Skype.

    You might be interested in this article, “E-mails hurt IQ more than pot”: . The statement that shocked me was:

    bq. He found the IQ of those who tried to juggle messages and work fell by 10 points—the equivalent to missing a whole night’s sleep and more than double the 4-point fall seen after smoking marijuana.

    If you read the actual report you’ll find that the act of reading an email message while talking on the phone reduces your IQ. If you don’t read the email, you have a higher IQ.

    I schedule when I read email to two or three times a day. This allows me to concentrate on my work and get more done. I do use IM to contact co-workers when I need information from them, but often ignore IMs from co-workers until I have a break. I find that I can’t go a week without some contact, but I think that may be different for each person.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  16. The system has conditioned us to long wait times and music while we wait for telephone interaction.  It seems as if we almost don’t know how to handle interpersonal interactions anymore especially on the telephone

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  17. this is a very interesting read , thanks

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  18. Enjoyed the article very much because I just started a photography company with two friends of mine who are photographers and I’m the web developer. So we decided to put our professions together to start up the company and after reading your article that a lot of what is said is things that we have implemented or that we will now start implementing. I love this type of work enviornment the virtual workspace.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  19. and designers are sometimes completely different people.  They can be odd and difficult to work with, but you have to have an understanding of the tedious things they do in order to function well with them.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  20. I’ll thank you for writing the article! We got in business just a few weeks ago - a dozen of designers, web developer and marketing professionals as a team. Your aspects can be used in our daily work to organise the group and to meet with success. Every human has a different point of view and that’s the interesting thing to work with.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.

    Copy & paste the code below to embed this comment.
  22. Sorry, commenting is closed on this article.