The A List Apart Blog Presents:

“Designers Shouldn’t Code” is the Wrong Answer to the Right Question

Article Continues Below

A new spin on an old chestnut. In “Designers Shouldn’t Code” is the Wrong Answer to the Right Question, designer Joshua Seiden succinctly articulates why some professionals fear that too much knowledge of code will lead to designs being based around implementation models instead of a user’s mental model; why that concern is overblown; and why having HTML, CSS, and JavaScript in the design workflow can make for a much better end-product.

Here at ALA, of course, it’s preaching to the choir. But Seiden’s quick, clear framing of the case makes it a fine article to share with colleagues who believe front-end code doesn’t belong in a “real” designer’s practice.

3 Reader Comments

  1. Thanks Jeffrey, for touching this topic! Many people view code as a restriction to a designer but actually it is liberating as it opens up a whole new realm of creative possibilities. Your design is executed the way you want it to be.

    DbaiG
    Bolee.com

  2. Maybe designers should’t code, but they need to have a deep understanding how their designs can impact the code. Basically talking about responsive design.

Got something to say?

We have turned off comments, but you can see what folks had to say before we did so.

More from ALA

Design for Amiability: Lessons from Vienna

Computing was born in a Viennese café. Between 1928 and 1934, while Hitler plotted and Europe crumbled, a motley crew of mathematicians, philosophers, architects, and economists gathered weekly to puzzle out the limits of reason—and invented Computer Science in the process. What made their collaboration possible wasn't just brilliance (though they had plenty). It was amiability: the careful design of a social space where difficult people could disagree without destroying each other. Longtime A List Apart contributing author Mark Bernstein mines this forgotten history for lessons that might just save today's embattled web from its worst impulses. Spoiler: it involves better coffee service and the looming threat of public humiliation.

From Beta to Bedrock: Build Products that Stick.

Building towards bedrock means sacrificing some short-term growth potential in favour of long-term stability. But the payoff is worth it: products built with a focus on bedrock will outlast and outperform their competitors, and deliver sustained value to users over time. Liam Nugent shows us how.

User Research Is Storytelling

At a time when budgets for user experience research seem to have reached an all-time low, how do we get stakeholders and executives alike invested in this crucial discipline? Gerry Duffy walks us through how the research we conduct is much like telling a compelling story, complete with a three-act narrative structure, character development, and conflict resolution—with a happy ending for researchers and stakeholders alike.

Discover more from A List Apart

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading