Good designers, bad websites: a proposal

I want to discuss accessibility because it is the most important thing for making websites. Other A List Apart articles give you innovation and insight. This article will give you homework. These are just my personal views, but they’re pretty good.

Article Continues Below

I want to start off with a couple of statements, and you will agree:

  1. Designers are good people. I have never heard a designer say, “I don’t care if somebody can’t read this text”, “Not my fault if somebody can’t use this device”, or “Who cares if this is confusing?”
  2. Some designs exclude people. You have seen people unable to read the text on a website or app that somebody designed. You’ve seen people unable to use a physical device that somebody has designed. You’ve seen people utterly bamboozled while trying to use a service that somebody designed.

So what?#section2

The first question is, “Is this life-or-death stuff?” The answer is, “Yes.” In my favorite essay, This Is All There Is, Aral Balkan makes the point that pretty much everything that we design can affect life events and death events. Aral gives the example of how even a straightforward bus timetable app can affect life and death events, if we design it badly:

  • somebody might miss a life event, such as their daughter’s fifth birthday party; or
  • somebody might miss a death event, such as the chance to say goodbye to a dying grandmother.

The next—and frustrating—question is, “Why do some designs still exclude people?” After all, we know that:

  • not everybody can see perfectly;
  • not everybody can hear perfectly;
  • not everybody thinks the same way; and
  • not everybody moves the same way.

I think the answer is that there’s too much to recall. Consider, if you will, the wide variety of topics that A List Apart articles cover. Designers are expected to remember all of that guidance, plus all of the accessibility guidance, plus so much more. It is too much.

Recognizing accessibility issues while designing#section3

I’d like to point toward one possible solution, starting from Jakob Nielsen’s 10 Usability Heuristics for User Interface Design. These are from the mid-1990s, and—although there’s a good chance that you, gentle reader, are a lot younger than that—please bear with me. 

Seeing as the problem is that there’s too much to recall, I want to look at heuristic № 6, “Recognition rather than Recall.” Jakob Nielsen said that for users, information required to use the design should be visible or easily retrievable when needed. I suggest we tweak that to make life easier for designers. Let’s say that the information required to produce the design should be visible or easily retrievable when needed. In other words, let’s make it easier to recognise accessibility issues while we’re designing.

How are we going to do that? I really like the book A Web for Everyone—Designing Accessible User Experiences by Sarah Horton and Whitney Quesenbery. I really like this book not only because it includes a quote from me—actually two quotes, but I don’t like to boast—but because it includes personas that are perfect for helping us to recognise accessibility issues. That’s the good news. The even better news is that these personas are available now for free on the companion website to the book What Every Engineer Should Know About Digital Accessibility, again by Sarah Horton, with David Sloan this time.

Meet your users#section4

I’m going to introduce you to these personas now:

I want to throw one more persona at you now, because, well, A List Apart readers are overachievers. One of my favorite authors, Cennydd Bowles—who literally wrote the book on Future Ethics—says to create Personas Non Grata. In other words, every time we design something, we have to think about what a bad guy could do with that thing, and whom that might affect.

To actually use these personas while designing, I like what Eric Meyer and Sara Wachter-Boettcher in Design for Real Life call the Designated Dissenter: for each project that you work on, one of your teams should be responsible for asking, “Will this work for Vishnu?”, “How’s Trevor going to get on with this?”, and so on. 

Then, once you’ve used the personas to recognise the accessibility issues, you can look up the guidelines for whichever platforms you’re designing for: 

Your mission, should you choose to accept it#section5

I told you in the introduction of this article that I would give you homework. You thought I was joking. So, here’s your homework: I want you to grab the personas from the Know About Accessibility website, and use them throughout every design project to help you recognise accessibility issues while you work—and reclaim design for everyone.


NOTE: This article is based on “Recognise,” my five-minute presentation from Interaction Design Association (IxDA) Dublin’s Defuse (Design for Use) event in 2025.

39 Reader Comments

  1. Self-service kiosks are no longer just a trend they’re becoming an essential part of modern business operations. From reducing wait times and cutting operational costs to providing customers with faster, more personalized service, kiosks are reshaping industries like retail, banking, healthcare, and hospitality. With the right design and technology, they don’t just improve efficiency they also create a seamless and satisfying customer experience. Truly a smart step for businesses that want to stay competitive in today’s digital-first world

    1. Long-range FPV is one of the most peaceful and rewarding parts of the hobby. Instead of tight freestyle lines, you cruise over fields, forests and coastlines, covering distances that would be impossible with a regular drone. It is also the style that demands the most planning, because the farther you go, the less room for error.
      The core of any long-range build is efficiency. Larger propellers, typically 7 inches or more, combined with low-KV motors and a high-capacity battery, give the best flight time. Many pilots choose a 6S or higher-voltage pack, often in a lithium-ion format, because Li-ion cells offer more energy per gram than standard LiPo. A well-built long-range drone can fly for twenty minutes or more, depending on weight and style.
      The control link is the next critical piece. A long-range link such as ExpressLRS on a sub-GHz band can keep you connected well beyond where a normal link would drop. Pair it with good antennas on both sides, and test your failsafe thoroughly. If you lose control, the drone should either return home or land safely, not fly off into the distance.
      GPS is almost a requirement. A GPS module gives you position data, a return-to-home option and a way to find the drone if it lands in an unexpected place. Set a home point before takeoff, confirm the satellite count, and check that the return-to-home altitude clears nearby trees and buildings.
      If you are choosing parts for such a build, the GPS modules, antennas and larger motors listed at https://zaruba-store.com/ are a good place to compare options. Look for GPS units with a reliable compass and a good satellite lock, and choose antennas that match your video and control frequencies.
      Video range deserves its own attention. Analog long-range systems with high-power transmitters and directional antennas on the goggles can reach impressive distances. Digital systems can look beautiful, but the picture may freeze earlier than analog would. Whatever you choose, keep an eye on signal strength and turn back before the link gets weak.
      Plan every flight. Check the weather, wind direction and temperature, and remember that a headwind on the way out becomes a tailwind on the way back, but the opposite can also happen. Set a battery rule such as turning back at 50 percent, and never fly farther than you are willing to walk to recover the drone.
      Safety and legality come first. Know your local rules about visual line of sight, maximum altitude and restricted areas. Many places require a spotter or a visual observer for FPV flights. Never fly over people, near airports or over private property without permission.
      Long-range flying rewards patience and preparation. With the right gear, a clear plan and respect for the rules, it offers some of the most beautiful flights in the hobby.

  2. Great design alone doesn’t guarantee a good website experience when usability, accessibility, and system reliability are not aligned with user expectations and real-world workflows. Enterprise software ecosystems often face similar challenges at scale, where performance and support quality directly affect user satisfaction, and https://microsoft-365.pissedconsumer.com/review.html is frequently referenced when discussing customer experiences, service reliability, and overall platform usability in professional productivity tools.

    1. Get the best career counselling in Vadnagar
      Vadnagar is one of the developing cities in Gujarat state. CareerNaksha’s Career guidance helps individuals set realistic and achievable career goals. This involves considering both short-term and long-term objectives based on the individual’s aspirations, resources, and the requirements of their chosen field. CareerNaksha’s career counselling and Career guidance include practical advice on job search strategies. This may involve assistance with resume writing, cover letter preparation, job interview techniques, and networking skills. The goal is to equip individuals with the tools to navigate the job market effectively.
      for more information and guidance please visit us :

  3. The tension Alan identifies at the very start is real and honestly a little uncomfortable to sit with: designers are genuinely good people, and yet some designs still shut people out. It’s tempting to resolve that tension by pointing at systems, timelines, or client budgets. But the “too much to recall” framing feels more honest and more actionable. It’s not a character problem, it’s a cognitive load problem.
    The pivot to Nielsen’s heuristic №6 — flipping “recognition over recall” from a principle for users into a tool for designers — is the kind of reframing that actually sticks. It’s not a new framework to memorize on top of everything else. It’s a way to embed the right questions into the existing design process. That’s the difference between advice people nod at and advice people actually use.
    The personas are the practical heart of this piece. What I appreciate is that they’re not generic archetypes — they’re people with specific voices and specific frustrations. “When a site is confusing, I just leave” and “Don’t make me work so hard” are the kind of lines that stay in your head while you’re making a decision about a dropdown or a font size. That’s exactly the point — you need them present in the room, not filed away in a documentation tab you’ll maybe open someday.
    The Designated Dissenter idea from Design for Real Life is worth emphasizing too. Accessibility advocacy can get lonely when it feels like one person’s job. Making it a rotating team responsibility changes both the ownership and the culture.
    My only thought: it would be interesting to see how these personas could be adapted for native mobile design specifically, where accessibility patterns diverge pretty meaningfully from web WCAG guidance. The foundation is the same, but the implementation layer gets complicated fast.
    Either way — this is the kind of homework worth doing. Bookmarking the Know About Accessibility personas right now.

  4. This is a thought-provoking article that challenges a common assumption in the web industry—that good designers automatically create good websites. I really like how the article explores the reality that even talented, well-intentioned designers can unintentionally create experiences that exclude users when accessibility, usability, and real-world constraints are overlooked. The proposal of using accessibility personas as a practical design tool is especially interesting because it helps teams identify potential barriers earlier in the design process rather than treating accessibility as a final checklist item. Content like this is valuable because it encourages designers to think beyond aesthetics and focus on creating websites that work well for everyone.

    I also write blog posts on this website https://hoteltheresidency.com/, where we share travel experiences, destination guides, and accommodation tips for travelers planning visits to culturally rich cities like Jodhpur. Our platform is connected with a boutique hotel that offers comfortable rooms, warm hospitality, and a peaceful stay in the heart of the city with easy access to major attractions. Through our blogs, we aim to help travelers discover authentic local experiences as they plan a relaxing and memorable stay.

  5. I found your take on how even the best designers can create inaccessible websites really eye-opening! It’s interesting to ponder how the pursuit of aesthetics sometimes overshadows usability. Do you think there’s a way for designers to prioritize accessibility without compromising their creative vision? Also, could tools or platforms like Geometry Dash Wave play a role in raising awareness about these issues among both designers and users? I’d love to hear more about your thoughts on integrating accessibility education into design curriculums!

  6. Thanks for this post. I am relatively new to Enhancing Web Design: Recognizing Accessibility Issues Now and your explanation of accessibility issues cleared up a few things for me. Is there a particular resource you would recommend for going deeper into escorts in Guwahati?

  7. The ‘this article gives you homework’ framing made me smile, and honestly accessibility being treated as the most important thing rather than an afterthought is the right hill to die on. Too many beautiful portfolios fall apart the moment you try to navigate them with a keyboard. Looking forward to the actual homework.

  8. This explanation of hindi viramchinh very useful. It clearly describes different punctuation marks and their usage, making Hindi grammar easier to understand for students and learners.

  9. The explanation of sangya is clear and helpful for understanding basic Hindi grammar. It makes it easier to identify naming words and improves overall language learning for students.

  10. sarvanam is an important part of Hindi grammar that helps avoid repeating nouns in sentences. Learning Sarvanam makes sentence formation smoother, clearer, and easier to understand in everyday communication.

  11. The topic visheshan ke prakar is very useful for understanding Hindi grammar. Learning the different types of adjectives helps students improve sentence formation and use descriptive words more accurately in writing.

  12. I found this explanation of kriya in hindi very helpful. It clearly describes action words with simple examples, making grammar concepts easier to understand for students and beginners alike.

  13. Understanding vachan ki paribhasha is important for learning Hindi grammar correctly. It helps identify whether a noun or pronoun is singular or plural, making sentence formation clearer and more accurate.

  14. Excellent perspective. I especially liked the idea of identifying accessibility issues during the design process instead of treating them as something to fix later. Building accessibility into the workflow from the beginning leads to better user experiences for everyone. As a developer working with AI-powered web applications, I’ve found that combining accessible design with modern AI tools helps create products that are both innovative and inclusive. Thanks for sharing such a practical and thought-provoking article. Email: farrukhhafeezdev@gmail.com

  15. The demand for online gaming platforms continues to increase, and 6sixgame.pk is becoming a preferred choice for many users. Its simple interface, fast performance, and smooth navigation create an enjoyable experience. The platform is regularly updated to provide better features and improved usability for all players.

  16. hh98 game offers a modern online gaming experience with a clean design and responsive interface. Players appreciate its quick access, stable performance, and easy navigation. Regular updates help ensure that users continue to enjoy a smooth and reliable platform.

  17. This post showed me that creating consumer access is like running a monkey mart store! Customers include monkeys who like bananas, milk, or walking slowly. If shelves are untidy and aisles are tight, prohibiting customers from shopping, the store will fail instantly. Good design lets everyone find what they need, and no one gets left behind!

  18. Great perspective! A talented designer can make a huge difference to a website’s usability, visual appeal, and overall user experience. Good design is not just about looking beautiful—it’s about making the website clear, functional, and easy to navigate.

  19. Thank you for shedding light on the often-overlooked accessibility issues in web design. I’ve encountered so many beautifully designed sites that are frustratingly unusable! This has inspired me to prioritize inclusivity in my own projects, like granny 1

  20. I really enjoyed y 999 game post. The topic was explained in a way that felt natural and easy to follow. The information is useful, and the writing style makes the content enjoyable to read. I learned a few new things that I had not considered before. Thank you for taking the time to create such a helpful and informative article for readers like me. https://y999game.pk/

  21. I really enjoyed hh 988 game post. The topic was explained in a way that felt natural and easy to follow. The information is useful, and the writing style makes the content enjoyable to read. I learned a few new things that I had not considered before. Thank you for taking the time to create such a helpful and informative article for readers like me. https://hh988.net.pk/

  22. Really enjoyed this perspective on accessibility and design. The idea of using personas to spot accessibility issues during the design process is especially practical. It’s a good reminder that great design isn’t just about how something looks—it’s about making sure everyone can actually use it.

  23. This really captures something that is easy to forget when judging a designer purely by the finished website. The final result can be shaped by budgets, deadlines, technical limitations, client decisions, and content that the designer may have had little control over. I recently tried to learn more here while comparing a few very different sites, and it made me pay more attention to individual design decisions rather than simply deciding whether I liked the whole page. Looking at the reasoning behind the work probably tells you much more about a designer’s ability than a screenshot of the final product.

  24. Users who enjoy exploring different online gaming platforms can use 1 ee game to find gaming-related content in one convenient place. The website has a simple structure that makes it easier to browse through its available sections. With straightforward navigation and easy-to-follow information, visitors can spend more time exploring the platform instead of dealing with a complicated interface.

  25. Users who enjoy exploring different online gaming platforms can use 1 ee game to find gaming-related content in one convenient place. The website has a simple structure that makes it easier to browse through its available sections. With straightforward navigation and easy-to-follow information, visitors can spend more time exploring the platform instead of dealing with a complicated interface.

  26. 1188 pkr game gives online gaming enthusiasts a convenient place to explore relevant content and discover the features offered through the platform. Its layout is designed to keep navigation simple, allowing visitors to move between sections with minimal effort.

  27. Exploring gaming websites becomes easier when the available information is presented in a clear and accessible way. 1 ee game provides a user-friendly platform where visitors can browse through gaming-related sections and explore the content available.

  28. Exploring gaming websites becomes easier when the available information is presented in a clear and accessible way. 1 ee game provides a user-friendly platform where visitors can browse through gaming-related sections and explore the content available.

  29. People who enjoy mobile gaming often like having new platforms to explore when they want something different. we 999 provides users with an option to discover gaming-related content and explore the available information.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More from ALA

Designed for a Dead Language

Every language app in your pocket inherited a teaching method built for Latin. Understanding why that happened is a more useful design lesson than anything the apps themselves can teach you.
Uncategorized

Design for Amiability: Lessons from Vienna

Computing was born in a Viennese café. Between 1928 and 1934, while Hitler plotted and Europe crumbled, a motley crew of mathematicians, philosophers, architects, and economists gathered weekly to puzzle out the limits of reason—and invented Computer Science in the process. What made their collaboration possible wasn't just brilliance (though they had plenty). It was amiability: the careful design of a social space where difficult people could disagree without destroying each other. Longtime A List Apart contributing author Mark Bernstein mines this forgotten history for lessons that might just save today's embattled web from its worst impulses. Spoiler: it involves better coffee service and the looming threat of public humiliation.